COMMENTARY: Judging the court

  • Ambiga: Bersih’s ‘People’s Tribunal’ a ‘moral force’ to investigate electoral fraud
    Ambiga: Bersih’s ‘People’s Tribunal’ a ‘moral force’ to investigate electoral fraud

    KUALA LUMPUR, May 21 — Bersih 2.0’s “People’s Tribunal” may not have any legal standing but will serve as a “moral force” to investigate allegations of electoral fraud, said Datuk Ambiga Sreenavasan when defending the polls watchdog’s final attempt at proving wrongdoing in the May 5 polls.

  • Cease attacks on DAP, Karpal tells Tunku Aziz
    Cease attacks on DAP, Karpal tells Tunku Aziz

    KUALA LUMPUR, May 20 ― DAP chairman Karpal Singh warned Tunku Abdul Aziz Ibrahim today to cease and desist from attacking DAP and its leaders, saying legal action will otherwise be taken against the party’s former vice-chairman.

  • Raja Nazrin: Integrity, commitment to fight graft can improve BN’s image
    Raja Nazrin: Integrity, commitment to fight graft can improve BN’s image

    BY CLARA CHOOIASSISTANT NEWS EDITOR KUALA LUMPUR, May 20 ― A government with integrity and that is committed to wielding the rule of law to weed out corruption without fear, favour or political interference can redeem itself in the eyes of the public, Perak Regent Raja Dr Nazrin Shah said today.  The son of Perak Ruler Sultan Azlan Shah pointed out that it had been this very commitment to integrity that led Barisan Nasional (BN) to a staggering victory in Election 2004 but the coalition’s

  • PKR: GST will ‘punish the poor’, BN should cut corruption first
    PKR: GST will ‘punish the poor’, BN should cut corruption first

    PETALING JAYA, May 20 — The Barisan Nasional (BN) government should not introduce the “regressive” Goods and Services Tax (GST) which, together with promised tax cuts, will “punish the poor”, PKR’s Wong Chen has said.

  • Despite EC’s remarks, Rafizi will still bring fraud evidence to People’s Tribunal
    Despite EC’s remarks, Rafizi will still bring fraud evidence to People’s Tribunal

    PETALING JAYA, May 20 — PKR’s Rafizi Ramli said he would still bring proof of electoral fraud to the People’s Tribunal despite the Election Commission (EC) saying that the tribunal set up by polls watchdog Bersih lacks legal standing.

Islamabad (Dawn/ANN) - So now we know.

The moderates in the Supreme Court will go by the book, the hardliners will press for an early outcome, the prime minister will eventually go and the Pakistan People's Party (PPP) will elect yet another one.

What's the point to this farce?

Unhappily, that may be beside the point now.

The court can and should back off. But it seems to come down to this: in hounding the government to write the Swiss letter, it wants a PPP prime minister to implicitly state that the PPP boss is a corrupt man.

Letter written, legal repercussions or not, it will be there for all time to come on the historical record.

Surely there must be more?

It doesn't really matter. Asif Zardari knows that this is about humiliating him and he's called the court's bluff. One prime minister, two prime ministers, 10 prime ministers - he'll throw PMs at the court faster than it can knock them down.

Much has been made about the government's stubbornness. Write the damn letter, everyone says. But let's look at it from Zardari's perspective.

Everyone's corrupt here. Everyone's heard the rumours about everyone, politicians, generals, bureaucrats and yes, even judges.

Every constituency politician by definition is corrupt here. Sustaining your base and milking it for votes come election time is an expensive business. Running a party with a national vote bank is infinitely more expensive.

Zardari just happens to be better at corruption than most. In his mind, why is that his fault?

Since he's come to power he hasn't done anything to any of the other players. He hasn't chucked anyone in jail, hasn't had cases registered against his opponents, hasn't set NAB or the IB or the tax collectors on his political rivals.

There was the misjudgment with governor's rule in Punjab in '09 but the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) has landed more punches than it's suffered.

As for the allies of convenience, the Awami National Party in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the Muttahida Quami Movement in Karachi, the Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid in Punjab and Islamabad, each has raked it in as much as circumstances have allowed.

Nothing has been done to the court. The judges wanted a hermetically sealed judiciary in which they alone decide who can or cannot become a judge. So Zardari gave them a constitutional amendment, even though it meant overriding his crowning constitutional achievement, the 18th Amendment.

Malik Riaz was tweaked by the presidency when the going threatened to get really rough but then the ouster of the PM was quickly accepted. To try and save the next PM, all the government has done is pass a new law.

There are no jiyalas stationed outside the Supreme Court. There is no Sindh card or Seraiki card being flaunted around Sindh or southern Punjab.

The attorney general has an axe to grind with Court of Chaudhry but pot shots taken here and there don't amount to much. The chief justice has claimed parliament isn't supreme, but no one has stood up in parliament to shut down the chief justice.

What is Zardari's goal?

Get his government past the finish line and fight for re-election in a fractured, polarised polity. The aim isn't noble but neither is it wanton or destructive.

Here is a man who's mocked, ridiculed, derided, spat on, abused, threatened and worse. For much of his adult life he lived in the shadow of a woman who was one of the most famous politicians in the world.

When his chance came, he didn't aim high. He knows his limitations and set his sights accordingly.

In the rough and tumble world of Pakistani politics he has a skin thick enough to shrug off the attacks and a mind sharp enough to know everyone has a price.

So he could deliver something that no one before him could: a full-term government.

We - you and me, the unfortunate everymen in this blighted land - don't get to pick what happens to us. But surely we can call it out for what it is.

The question is simple, why should the court bring an early end to this government?

Who's right, who's wrong, who's good, who's bad, who's to blame less or more, set all of that aside for a minute.

The thing I like best about Zardari is that he can't stick around for a day more than the people permit and he just doesn't have the power to ever, ever take that right away from the people.

A judge may endorse an extended caretaker set-up or anoint yet another would-be saviour. A general may use the threat of the gun to do as he sees fit with this country.

But come September 2013, Zardari will have to face an election. And come March 2013, his government will have to face an election.

I, like many, am terrified at the prospect of another five years for Zardari.

If he can rule as incompetently and disastrously as he has and yet drag the PPP and himself to another electoral victory, it is truly frightening to imagine what he'd do the next five years.

But there is no certainty that will happen. In fact, in their heart of hearts, the PPP is worried about the verdict the electorate may deliver and increasingly concerned about their ability to manipulate that verdict.

Why should the court deny us the opportunity to find out?

Because it can? Because it wants to? Because it believes it knows better about what's good for Pakistan? That simply isn't good enough.

You and I may not be able to stop the court from doing what it has decided must be done. But we can certainly judge it.

And the court should know, that judgment isn't very pleasant right now.

The writer is a member of staff.

Loading...

Comments on Yahoo! pages are subject to our link to Comments Guidelines. You are responsible for any content that you post. Yahoo! is not responsible or liable in any way for comments posted by its users. Yahoo! does not in any way endorse or support comments made by its users.

  • Utusan: Tiada iklan AirAsia sehingga Azran Osman Rani minta maaf The Malaysian Insider
    Utusan: Tiada iklan AirAsia sehingga Azran Osman Rani minta maaf

    KUALA LUMPUR, 19 Mei — Harga iklan syarikat penerbangan AirAsia lebih murah daripada iklan-iklan kecil yang lain, kata Awang Selamat dalam akhbar Mingguan Malaysia hari ini, serta menggesa ketua pegawai eksekutif anak syarikatnya, AirAsiaX, Azran Osman Rani, meminta maaf.

  • Chinese business boycott will hurt Malay consumers, says ex-MIER director The Malaysian Insider
    Chinese business boycott will hurt Malay consumers, says ex-MIER director

    KUALA LUMPUR, May 20 — The call to boycott Chinese businesses is a double-edged weapon, former Malaysian Institute of Economic Research executive director Datuk Dr Ariff Abdul Kareem said today, explaining that the campaign would also end up hurting Malay consumers through deprivation of their daily needs.

  • Dua termasuk anggota polis cedera ditetak di balai polis Bernama

    SEGAMAT, 18 Mei (Bernama) -- Dua lelaki termasuk seorang anggota polisPasukan Gerakan Am Batalion Keenam, Bakri, Muar, cedera setelah diserang limalelaki bersenjata parang di kawasan Balai Polis Labis di sini hari ini.Ketua Polis Daerah Segamat Supt Mohd Kamil Sukaimi berkata dalam kejadiankira-kira pukul 11 pagi itu, anggota polis berkenaan mengalami kecederaan parahdi bahagian kepala, kaki kanan, dan anggota tubuh badan, manakala rakannya hanyamengalami cedera ringan. ...

  • Voting denial proves phantom voters, integrity of ICs in doubt, says Rafizi The Malaysian Insider
    Voting denial proves phantom voters, integrity of ICs in doubt, says Rafizi

    PETALING JAYA, May 20 — PKR’s Rafizi Ramli today offered evidence of phantom voters, which he alleged was widespread fraud that could potentially “discredit” the recently-concluded general election, besides putting the integrity of Malaysia’s identity cards (IC) in doubt.

  • Zahid jangan campur tangan urusan polis, kata Rafizi The Malaysian Insider
    Zahid jangan campur tangan urusan polis, kata Rafizi

    Oleh Mohd Farhan Darwis