Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Why no-one helped bleeding toddler in China

    Could the fear of being falsely accused or sued in court have resulted in people ignoring the bloodied body of a two-year-old girl who lay dying on a street in China?

    In a strange twist to the tragic hit-and-run accident in the southern Chinese city of Foshan, online commentators in China are saying that these passers-by could possibly have refused to help precisely because they feared being accused of injuring the girl.

    According to China Digital Times, netizens said there is a fear of extortion among the Chinese who witness public injury.

    The video of the accident, which has since gone viral, shows two-year-old Wang Yue being ignored by nearly 20 passers-by even as she lay dying after being run over twice by vans. A trash collector eventually later notices her and alerts her mother, who rushes her to hospital.

    The toddler is now in a coma and is likely to remain in a vegetative state if she survives, according to reports quoting the Guangzhou Military District General Hospital’s head of neurosurgery.

    Online commentators pointed to a 2006 case wherein a resident of Nanjing, Peng Yu, helped an old woman who had fallen only to have her accuse him of causing the injury.

    A judge subsequently ruled in favour of the plaintiff, saying that Peng would not have helped the woman if he did not cause the fall. The case was later settled in an agreement but Peng still paid 10 per cent of the costs.

    This controversial ruling seems to have eroded the country’s ethics, netizens fear.

    A recent online poll found that in China, 84 per cent of respondents would not offer assistance to an elderly person who falls on the street for fear of extortion, reported the site.

    In August this year, a bus driver in east China’s Jiangsu province helped an 81-year-old woman lying on the ground by the side of her overturned bicycle.

    She later told the police the bus driver had hit her but a video camera on the bus showed she was lying.

    A month later, an 88-year-old man in Wuhan fell on the streets about 100 meters from his home and remained lying face down on the ground, until an ambulance arrived ninety minutes later, according to a China Daily report.

    He died because his respiratory tract was clogged by a nosebleed, but might have survived if someone turned him over, the report noted. But none of the passes-by in the Wuhan, Hubei province offered a hand.

    Watch the footage (viewer discretion advised):

    How do you feel about this article?

     

    757 comments

    • joyce  •  7 months ago
      So disturbing... :-(
    • bienvenido  •  7 months ago
      Maybe they are too many (over populated)
    • Muhammad Noor  •  7 months ago
      lol Yasmin I guess he can't even have the chance to call out his mum name.
    • Ong  •  7 months ago
      Idiot judge and idiotic legal system. The accused is deemed innocent until proven guilty, in China this is probably the other way round: deemed guilty until proven innocent. These cases would continue cos officials wouldn't care less unless it is to fill their pockets with cash.
      • Chronotee 7 months ago
        If not wrong, Taiwan also like that, i mean deemd guilty until proven innocent
      • Run Amok 7 months ago
        Idiot judges should be run over by a truck on their legs!
        Look what they has done!!
      • cloak 7 months ago
        he he same here is the Philippines, squatter squat in your land, land owner ends up paying the price ...
    • Joe  •  7 months ago
      Really sick!! The hit-and-run driver should have his legs run over and left to suffer the pain. Maybe like this he would realise what he had done.
      • Lam 7 months ago
        and eyes drag out too since its useless to him as he doesn't use it at all...
      • Nanyang 7 months ago
        Gouge out e eyes lah, Lam. U n Joe r as sick as those 2 drivers, but I like. LOL.
      • true blue singa 7 months ago
        we shld have a real life case of the movie "hostel" for these chinamen. But then again they're probably not even worth 5bucks.
    • Freedom  •  7 months ago
      This is China & there are here in Singapore.....We r doom....!
      • Lam 7 months ago
        Yes its a warning to all people esp the CHINESE here in Singapore...DO NOT practice this here...do the right thing and right thing only...i.e. HELP!
      • dan 7 months ago
        We are sure "DOOM" Singapore Food Court "COOK" there are "China"people. Do you think heartless "China" people will "COOK" for U.....???
      • Anthony 7 months ago
        Singapore even worst... If u ram down ppl, just kill them.Then u will only be fine less than 10k.
    • Elf  •  7 months ago
      say like those 18 people that walk past didn't bother because they afraid of wrongly accuse. I believe none felt that way. stupid china shit.
      • teo 7 months ago
        Too many people in PRC so lives are cheap. Many years ago I witness an old man died in front of a railway station. Many people use the station but none cared. Singapore will one day be like that as population increase and people are too busy making ends meet.
      • green lantern 7 months ago
        When the government lost the moral compass, next will be the people.
      • GWR 7 months ago
        It's the govt mentality, their education policy and the cost of living that make their people dun really care about others, only care about self interest, sounds familiar?? Thanks to 10yrs cultural revolution from 1966-1976 and China's policy of opening its door to the world in 1979?
    • see bei du lan  •  7 months ago
      just heard the phone conversation, 1st driver knowingly hit the toddler but still run over her just to make sure she die so that pay lessen compensation. omg! what kind of law is that. I am shame on you China man. I dun want in associated with china any more, I am a Singapore chinese.
      • E 7 months ago
        cannot be helped...your garment say must learn and speak mandarin to welcome them here.......
      • vampi 7 months ago
        when I tour china, I heard one guy comment on a accident there 'it doesnt matter that a few people died in accidents, we have a huge populaton'.
      • Coco 7 months ago
        yeah man.the china men are pest to SINGAPORE. They bring bad attitude to singapore and rob our jobs and house become expensive.Shame on the ruling party who import them and bring misery to singaporeans.
    • BA  •  7 months ago
      Just horrified by the act of these cold blooded people !
    • Robbie Fanatic  •  7 months ago
      NO EXCUSES FOR THEM!!!! THEY COULD HAVE CALL THE POLICE AND BLOCK THE ROAD!!!!!!!!! DAMN IT!!!!!!!!! HOPE THEY DIE SOON!!!!!!!!!!
    • Sunny  •  7 months ago
      Please punish the two hard hearted drivers , the penalty should nothing less than excution.
    • Tong Tahi  •  7 months ago
      If a person conscious is clear, whatever the reason may be, that person can be an instant hero!
    • Ibrahim  •  7 months ago
      This two driver is not human. I hope china government will find them out and they will be henged by coart even the passers who saw the kid like this but never care.
    • Lost hope  •  7 months ago
      As you can see, I hope all china chinese in Singapore will able to understand it is all this kind of attitube that have scare us off. Not because we don't like you, we are very frighten of you.
    • Henry  •  7 months ago
      where are the parents?
      the driver has committed murder by what i can gather in the picture.
      ok murder 2nd degree.
    • Hokkien Peng  •  7 months ago
      This type of pattern also have. I tell you all. Never trust Tiong Kok Kia or Tiong Kok Bu. Their motive to Singapore is to Con and Con all your hard earn money. They Wayang-Wayang here & there. Chin-Gow-Cho-Hee. Don't know how many Singapore man die in these Kani-nia's hand. Worst, they that break-up their loving families. Kena, you damn bloody Suay.
    • Nebelwerfer  •  7 months ago
      I hope the Chinese Authority would prosecute the drivers and making their families pay for the bullets.
    • malou  •  7 months ago
      the mere fact that the driver saw the kid, he should have stopped. Its almost 2 meters away, its imposible that he didn't see her. If he claims that he didnt see her, passer-by should have called their "proper authorities" ambulance or police.
    • *Norish*  •  7 months ago
      Not only China people are loud, they are pure heartless too! I hope and pray hard that this toddler survives. My prayers goes to you little yue yue!
    • Nerissa  •  7 months ago
      Oh i'm overly disappointed in her mum. She got no feelings at all. The way she pick up her child is like picking up a rubbish no sadness at all. What on earth is this kind woman.

    Most Popular

    • Manji: Allah made gays and lesbians, too
      Manji: Allah made gays and lesbians, too

      INTERVIEW Unapologetic for her defence of the gay and lesbian lifestyle, controversial liberal-Islam author Irshad Manji has challenged critics to explain how Allah in all His glory could have made “misfits or abominations”.                

    • Anwar claims symbolic win after former prosecutor joins legal team
      Anwar claims symbolic win after former prosecutor joins legal team

      KUALA LUMPUR, May 22 — Opposition Leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim claimed a symbolic victory today in having the man who unsuccessfully prosecuted him for sodomy join his legal team to defend an illegal assembly charge, pointing out that someone who was in government did not want to be a part of what he called the “dirtiness”.

    • Umno ‘needs’ Gerakan, MCA to win Penang, says state BN boss
      Umno ‘needs’ Gerakan, MCA to win Penang, says state BN boss

      KUALA LUMPUR, May 23 — Penang Barisan Nasional (BN) chief Teng Chang Yeow has insisted that Umno “needs” Gerakan and MCA to wrest the state from Pakatan Rakyat (PR) in the coming polls, although the Malay party was the only one among the three that won seats in Election 2008.

    POLL
    Loading...
    Poll Choice Options