Allah judgment flawed, can jeopardise Najib’s job, say jurists

  • Court of Appeal strikes out charge against sex bloggers, says not applicable to non-Muslims
    Court of Appeal strikes out charge against sex bloggers, says not applicable to non-Muslims

    The Court of Appeal today struck out a charge under the Penal Code against two sex bloggers on grounds it was not applicable to non Muslims. A three-man bench led by Datuk Wira Mohtarudin Baki said the charge under Section 298A was not enforceable against Alvin Tan (Tan Jye Yee) and Vivian Lee (Lee May Ling). They had appealed to have the... …

  • MH370 scrutiny on Malaysia deals wild card in Anwar case
    MH370 scrutiny on Malaysia deals wild card in Anwar case

    The intense global scrutiny brought upon Malaysia's government over the fate of flight MH370 has tossed a wild card into its controversial efforts to send opposition leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim back to jail. Just hours before the Malaysia Airlines plane disappeared on March 8, a court overturned Anwar's 2012 acquittal on sodomy charges he... …

  • Two-thirds of underwater search done, no sign of MH370
    Two-thirds of underwater search done, no sign of MH370

    Two-thirds of the planned underwater search for missing Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 has been completed, with no signs so far of the jet, Australian officials said today. As many as 10 military aircraft and 11 ships are taking part in the search for the aircraft, which was carrying 239 people when it vanished on March 8 en route from Kuala... …

  • Pakatan must understand Kelantan’s hudud first before supporting it, says Anwar
    Pakatan must understand Kelantan’s hudud first before supporting it, says Anwar

    The model and implementation of hudud law which the Kelantan government is preparing to introduce needs to be understood in-depth first, said Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. "We must understand what the hudud law is about first before Pakatan Rakyat coalition parties support the Kelantan government's plans," said the opposition leader last night.... …

  • Indonesian Catholic woman’s khalwat case shows anomalies in Shariah court system
    Indonesian Catholic woman’s khalwat case shows anomalies in Shariah court system

    An Indonesian Catholic woman is in a bind after being found guilty of committing 'khalwat' (close proximity) by the Penang Shariah court two years ago. Despite not being a Muslim, Halimah, 42, was charged and convicted in the Shariah court, and now cannot get her case quashed due a lack of such provision in the state's Shariah law. Lawyer... …

  • Mini-submarine fails to detect any sign of MH370 after eight dives
    Mini-submarine fails to detect any sign of MH370 after eight dives

    Despite having scoured about two-thirds of the focused underwater search area in the Indian Ocean, no sign of missing Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 has been found, a statement from the Joint Agency Coordination centre (JACC) in Perth, Australia, said this morning. It said the Bluefin-21 autonomous underwater vehicle had completed its eighth... …

The Appeal Court decision on the Allah issue is "flawed" and "lacked common sense", say two constitutional lawyers while a retired judge warned that Datuk Seri Najib Razak's position as prime minister has now become vulnerable.

In an immediate reaction to the Court of Appeal ruling that the word Allah cannot be used by the Catholic weekly, the Herald, and was exclusive to Muslims in this country, a former Federal Court judge told The Malaysian Insider the verdict had far-reaching implications to Christians in Sabah and Sarawak.

The retired judge, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, also pointed out that Muslim fundamentalists in the peninsula are pushing Putrajaya to also ban the use of the word in the Borneo states and that it was dangerous for Najib.

Both Sabah and Sarawak are considered a Barisan Nasional (BN) safe deposit as 47 of the 133 parliamentary seats won in the recent general election came from the Borneo states.

"Najib has to make a stand now. He cannot be silent anymore. By keeping silent it would mean he is supportive of this Muslim group and this could be dangerous to his position," the former judge said yesterday.

He pointed out that freedom of religion was one of the conditions agreed upon when Sabah, Sarawak, Singapore and the then Federation of Malaya formed Malaysia 50 years ago.

"The principle derived from the three judgments from the Court of Appeal bench was that Christians cannot use the word Allah and this contradicts the rights of Sabahans and Sarawakians who practice the faith," he said.

Christians in Sabah and Sarawak generally use the Al-Kitab, which is in Bahasa Malaysia and native languages, which also contain the word Allah.

The former judge said the chief ministers and BN lawmakers from both states should be concerned about the court decision as they would have deal with the 2.8 million Christian voters, most of them from both the Borneo states.

"With this political equation and rising public debate over the issue, there will be a lot of backdoor political discussions in the coming weeks."

He said there had always been talk that these states should disengage from Malaysia but Borneo politicians would use their political numbers to arm twist Putrajaya more so when their interests were at stake.

He said the myopic approach of the three judges had failed to take into account the prosperity, security and welfare of the nation.

"Religion alone does not fill the belly of the people," he said.

Lawyer Malik Imtiaz Sarwar said the judgment was flawed as the court did not consider whether there was basis to Putrajaya's argument that there would be public disorder if the Herald was allowed to use that word.

"Although the home minister has the discretion to ban the word, he should have exercised his powers reasonably," Malik said.

The constitutional lawyer pointed out that there were no breaches of peace at the time the condition was imposed by the home minister nor was there an imminent threat of public disorder.

He also felt that the court should not have taken upon itself to determine whether the word Allah was an integral part of the Christian faith.

"They should have relied on what the Catholic Church had presented in its submissions during appeal."

Malik said the judgment also gave the impression that Muslims were easily led astray and wondered whether Putrajaya allowed itself to be influenced by the views of "a small number of conservative Muslim groups".

"This matter should not have gone to court because it will now lead to divisions in society," he said, adding that an independent consultative mechanism should be set up to mediate sensitive religious matters.

Another constitutional lawyer, Fahri Azzat, said the verdict lacked common sense because the court ruled on the ban "to protect Muslims from being confused" and to "avoid public disorder".

This, he said, would make it look like Muslims were easily provoked, and needed protection and guidance.

"For many enlightened Muslims, the court ruling enforced the belief that the feudal mentality was still strong," he said.

Fahri added that the court ruling on the word "Allah" should not be seen as a "triumph by Muslims over Christians". – October 16, 2013

Follow @YahooMalaysia on LINE for daily news updates.

Comments on Yahoo pages are subject to our link to Comments Guidelines. You are responsible for any content that you post. Yahoo is not responsible or liable in any way for comments posted by its users. Yahoo does not in any way endorse or support comments made by its users.

  • In funeral procession, thousands chant ‘Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh’ (VIDEO) The Malay Mail Online
    In funeral procession, thousands chant ‘Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh’ (VIDEO)

    GEORGE TOWN, April 20 — The streets of Penang’s historical city centre roared with the voices of thousands calling out the name of their state’s beloved son — Karpal Singh.  Elbows jostled with... …

  • Education Backgrounds OF Those Who Have Been Devising The Education Policies Of Malaysia Easyuni.com
    Education Backgrounds OF Those Who Have Been Devising The Education Policies Of Malaysia

    Malaysia gained its independence in the year 1957 and since its early days laid stress on improving the quality of education at all levels. Throughout its five year plans, education has been an important development objective. Right in the first development plan itself the direct relationship between the rate of economic and social advancement on […] …

  • Raja Bomoh spouting mumbo-jumbo again The Malaysian Insider
    Raja Bomoh spouting mumbo-jumbo again

    Bomoh (shaman) Ibrahim Mat Zin (pic, third left) is in the headlines for the wrong reasons again, this time for conducting a cleansing ritual along KM306.1 of the North-South Expressway. The area has been in the spotlight since last Thursday after Bukit Gelugor MP Karpal Singh died when his Toyota Alphard was involved in a collision with a... …