Hudud impossible for now

  • Karpal Singh dies in road accident, son injured
    Karpal Singh dies in road accident, son injured

    Bukit Gelugor MP Karpal Singh died in a car accident on the North-South Expressway this morning near Gua Tempurung, Kampar in Perak. Police has confirmed the incident that happened shortly before 1am at KM301.6 of the expressway. Karpal, who would have turned 74 in June, was believed to be travelling from Kuala Lumpur to Penang to attend a... …

  • Sales of Malaysian products normal in China despite boycott call – Bernama
    Sales of Malaysian products normal in China despite boycott call – Bernama

    The sales of Malaysian products in China, particularly food and beverage (F&B) products, remain normal despite calls by Chinese netizens to boycott them following the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines (MAS) flight MH370. A Malaysian importer of various products here, Loh Wee Keng, said the sales of F&B products were normal, especially in... …

  • Detainee’s ‘sudden death’ in jail due to viral infection, say police – Bernama

    A man who was remanded by the police last week on a drug-related offence was found dead at the Jinjang police station lock-up in Kuala Lumpur early today. The police found A. Mogan, 48, on the floor of the cell and foaming at the mouth at 12.45am. Sentul police chief ACP Zakaria Pagan said after finding Mogan unconscious, the police called... …

  • Sea Dragon and other probes that can go deeper may take over if mini-sub fails, says CNN
    Sea Dragon and other probes that can go deeper may take over if mini-sub fails, says CNN

    The search for Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 is nearing the end of its 40th day without any significant development and CNN aviation consultant Mary Schiavo said underwater probes which can go deeper may be deployed if current efforts using a high-tech mini-submarine fails. The mini-submarine or autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV), known as... …

  • Police cadet delivers baby in toilet while under training
    Police cadet delivers baby in toilet while under training

    A police trainee who was undergoing training at the police training centre (PULAPOL) delivered a baby girl in a toilet at a hospital yesterday, three months after she was tested negative for pregnancy. A source said the trainee, delivered her baby in a toilet of the Kuala Lumpur Hospital at 11am. Both mother and child are in good health. It... …

  • Mahathir wants Causeway replaced with ‘Friendship Bridge’ to Singapore – Bernama
    Mahathir wants Causeway replaced with ‘Friendship Bridge’ to Singapore – Bernama

    Former Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad (pic) today suggested the removal of the Johor Causeway in order to build the Friendship Bridge proposed by the government.    He said the Johor Causeway causes various problems, mainly involving environmental issues and traffic congestion, in Johor Baru.   "If it is a bridge, then what need is... …

PETALING JAYA: Hudud, the Islamic system of criminal law, is destined to remain entangled in a series of legal, political and administrative processes that will prevent its application for a long time to come, says PAS secretary-general Datuk Mustafa Ali.

At the mention of the complexities that surround hudud — ranging from the implementation issues that it entails, the differing stances on the subject taken by Pakatan Rakyat coalition members and its incessant appearance in the headlines since 2008 — Mustafa chuckles.

“But you have never seen hudud being implemented,” he responds, drawing attention to the contrast between all the talk over the matter on the one hand, and the lack of any legal or practical steps taken to implement such laws, on the other.

Speaking to in an interview recently, the Islamic party strongman says that he would not be surprised if the issue makes another comeback as the general election approaches.

He says that although the Pakatan parties — PAS, DAP and PKR  — have “agreed to disagree” over the issue, it will not just go away as it is close to the heart of any Muslim and it is a matter of principle for followers of Islam to uphold.

“No Muslim, whether in PAS or Umno, can say that hudud is not in Islam or that it is against the teaching of Islam. But if you speak to an Umno person, although he would agree with this, there are so many ‘buts’ and ‘buts’ [to justify its lack of implementation],” he says.

Hudud, says Mustafa, must be discussed in a broader perspective, as it is a “very small” portion of the Islamic justice system.

“It is more of a deterrent than a form of punishment ... more to instil fear in the people. It is just a small part of all the different systems of life in Islam such as economics, education and social well-being. Hudud is a very small part of criminal law,” he said.

In what (for now) appears to be the last word on the issue, Pakatan decided in September 2011 that DAP will stick to its opposition to the issue and PAS cannot be forced to abandon its principle to implement the law.

Flanked by 20-odd top Pakatan leaders, the coalition’s head Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim had said then: “Pakatan respects the PAS initiatives and aspirations (to implement hudud in Kelantan), but we have to reach a consensus … DAP is opposed to that and PKR and PAS respect that decision”.

He also said the matter was a non-issue as the existence of the Second Syariah Kelantan Criminal Enactments 1993 and the Terengganu Syariah Criminal Enactments 2003 required amendments to the Federal Constitution.

Referring to these state laws, Mustafa reiterates that the passage of any laws containing elements of hudud must follow the democratic process.

“Even in Kedah (where PAS holds 16 out of 36 state seats), we don’t have the numbers to implement Hudud (or pass any related legislation),” he says, noting that the state laws passed in Kelantan and Terengganu were voted for by a two-thirds majority in their respective state assemblies.

“So at the moment it is a state matter. If at all it is [to be done on a national level], it must adhere to the democratic process, meaning even the passage of the bill must be done with the two-thirds majority,” he adds.

The PAS veteran says the law is difficult to implement effectively as it requires cooperation of national-level of bureaucracy.

“You need the cooperation of the Prisons Department, the Police and others. Without this, it cannot be implemented,” he says, referring to the intricate cross-agency cooperation needed.

As sensitive an issue as this may be to the Muslim psyche and despite the many obstacles that stand in the way of achieving a united mindset on its implementation in the bureaucracy, Mustafa says the issue is also being manipulated by Barisan Nasional coalition party, MCA to win political currency over its rival in the opposition, the DAP.

“The rhetoric is just to instil fear in the Chinese voter that a vote for DAP is a vote for hudud. But that is wrong for MCA to say especially when DAP doesn’t agree with the adoption of hudud,” says Mustafa.

“Eventually, people can see that it is just [MCA’s] political ploy,” he says.

For more stories, go to, the website for freedom of expression and fairness in articulation.


This article first appeared in The Edge Financial Daily, on Jan 10, 2013.

Follow @YahooMalaysia on LINE for daily news updates.

Comments on Yahoo pages are subject to our link to Comments Guidelines. You are responsible for any content that you post. Yahoo is not responsible or liable in any way for comments posted by its users. Yahoo does not in any way endorse or support comments made by its users.

  • ‘Huge’ Hindu, Buddhist statues against Islam, ex-judge says The Malay Mail Online
    ‘Huge’ Hindu, Buddhist statues against Islam, ex-judge says

    KUALA LUMPUR, April 16 — The “huge” statues at a Hindu temple in Batu Caves and Buddhist temple in Penang are an affront to Islam as the religion forbids idolatry, a retired Court of Appeals judge... …

  • Wreck hunter confident MH370 crash site found, says Aussie paper The Malaysian Insider
    Wreck hunter confident MH370 crash site found, says Aussie paper

    A wreck hunter is confident that the search teams had pinpointed the crash site of Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 and believes that the black boxes will be located soon, the Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) reports. David Mearns, director of Blue Water Recoveries told the ABC's 7.30 programme yesterday, he was confident that, because of their... …

  • ‘All the best’, Selangor MB tells Bible society at exit The Malay Mail Online
    ‘All the best’, Selangor MB tells Bible society at exit

    SHAH ALAM, April 15 — Selangor Mentri Besar Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim said today he wished the Bible Society of Malaysia (BSM) well on its decision to move its headquarters out to Kuala Lumpur to... …