Sabah lawyers offer to stand with Catholic Church in appeal against Allah ruling

  • Australia sees ‘regroup’ on MH370 search in a few days
    Australia sees ‘regroup’ on MH370 search in a few days

    Australia will decide in a few days whether to alter or scale back the search for missing Malaysia Airlines flight 370, but will consult all countries involved on any changes, Australia's ambassador to the United States said yesterday. Kim Beazley told CNN the search countries would "regroup and reconsider" if nothing is found in a section of... …

  • MAS plane bound for Bangalore makes emergency landing in KLIA after tyre bursts
    MAS plane bound for Bangalore makes emergency landing in KLIA after tyre bursts

    A Malaysia Airlines plane with 166 people on board was forced to make an emergency landing in Kuala Lumpur early today in another blow to its safety image after the loss of flight MH370. Flight MH192, bound for Bangalore, India, turned back to Kuala Lumpur after it was discovered that a tyre had burst on take-off, the airline said. "As... …

  • Academic: Seaweed farmers main suspects in turtle deaths
    Academic: Seaweed farmers main suspects in turtle deaths

    PETALING JAYA, April 21 — Seaweed farmers are believed to be responsible for the deaths of four green turtles found floating in the sea between Bum-Bum Island and Kulapuan Island in Semporna.... …

  • Bible, highway storm proves ‘Kajang Move’ right, its engineers say
    Bible, highway storm proves ‘Kajang Move’ right, its engineers say

    KUALA LUMPUR, April 21 — Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim has shown he is unfit to head Selangor as seen in his recent fumble of the bible seizure and the green light given for a 14.9km elevated highway... …

  • Mosti deny accusations that R&D grant of RM1.152 billion was abused – Bernama

    The Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation (Mosti) today denied allegations of abusing grants amounting to RM1.152 billion that was allocated for research and development (R&D). Its deputy minister Datuk Dr Abu Bakar Mohamad Diah said the allocation for the R&D was given to researchers or applicants using a tight procedure. He said... …

  • Singaporean tourist killed, 39 injured in bus accident, the third in 8 days – Bernama

    A Singaporean tourist was killed while 39 others were injured, including two drivers, when the double-decker tour bus they were travelling in plunged into a ravine at KM70 of the Kuantan-Segamat highway near Pekan, Pahang, this afternoon.  The bus, driven by a local driver, transporting 38 Singaporean tourists from Redang Island, Terengganu to... …

The Sabah Law Association (SLA) wants to stand side by side with the Catholic Church when the Allah case goes before the Federal Court, a sure sign of the widening impact of restricting the word to Muslims only.

The SLA met on Saturday and made the decision after concluding that the Court of Appeal ruling on October 14 had violated the constitutional rights of Christians in Sabah.

"The SLA will apply to be part of the proceedings in the Federal Court," a member of the association told The Malaysian Insider.

SLA president Datuk G.B.B. Naandy@Gaanesh is expected to issue an official statement soon.

The SLA decision to join the appeal came after reports on Saturday that Putrajaya had stopped the distribution of 2,000 copies of this week's edition of the Herald in Sabah when the consignment arrived at the Kota Kinabalu airport on Thursday. The weekly was cleared for distribution yesterday morning but the weekend break meant it could not be sent to churches.

The decision to stop the distribution came despite an assurance last Monday by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak that Christians in the state were free to use Allah in their worship and publications.

A check with civil lawyers revealed that the SLA could apply to be an intervener in the proceedings, just like Islamic councils which became parties to the action in the Court of Appeal.

Another way is for the Federal court to invite the SLA to come to court, while the third choice is for SLA to apply to hold a watching brief and address the judges. It was not immediately clear which
option the SLA would take.

On October 14, the Court of Appeal allowed Putrajaya's appeal to prohibit the Herald from using Allah because, in its judgment, the word was not an integral part of the Christian faith and practice.

The Catholic Church’s lawyers, meanwhile, said they would be filing a leave application early next week to appeal against the ruling.

Last week, The Malaysian Insider reported that politicians from East Malaysia argued that the controversial Court of Appeal ruling was a breach of the Malaysia agreement.

Constitutional lawyers also weighed in on the issue, saying it would clearly be a breach of the 1963 Malaysia agreement if East Malaysian Christians were to be barred from using the word Allah in any part of the federation.

Sabah State Reform Party (Star) chairman Datuk Dr Jeffrey Kitingan (pic, right) said the Court of Appeal ruling went against the first point of the agreement which touched on freedom of religion.

Point 1 of the 20-point condition that Sabah drew up and the 18-point condition Sarawak drew up, which Malaya had to agree to before forming Malaysia, stated that: “While there was no objection to Islam being the national religion of Malaysia, there should be no state religion in Borneo (Sarawak & Sabah), and the provisions relating to Islam in the present Constitution of Malaya should not apply to Borneo.”

Kitingan, a vocal proponent of restoring the full autonomy and rights of Sabah and Sarawak under the 20 and 18-point agreements, also pointed out that the country's first prime minister, Tunku Abdul Rahman, had given a clear assurance on religious freedom in Parliament on October 16, 1961.

He then quoted Tunku: “One reaction in the Borneo territories was that the Malaysia concept was an attempt to colonise the Borneo territories... the answer to this was, as I said before, it is legally impossible for the federation to colonise because we desire that they should join us in the federation in equal partnership, enjoying the same status between one another, so there is no fear that Malaysia will mean that there will be an imposition of Islam on Borneo... so everybody is free to practise whatever religion.”

Kitingan said Sabah natives marked the assurance of religious freedom in the Malaysia agreement by literally carving it in stone, the Batu Sumpah or Oath Stone.

“It essentially states that as long as this religious freedom is respected, we shall be loyal to Malaysia,” added Kitingan, who in 2010 founded the United Borneo Front (UBF), a non-governmental organisation aimed at safeguarding the rights of Sabah and Sarawak in the 20-point and 18-point agreements.

Echoing Kitingan's view that the Court of Appeal ruling had breached the agreement was Sarawak PKR chairman Baru Bian (pic, left).

“This decision is a betrayal of the undertaking given to our forefathers when they agreed to join in the formation of Malaysia,” Baru said.

“The rights of Sarawakians and Sabahans were also protected in the Government Paper 'Malaysia and Sarawak' dated January 4, 1962.”

Baru said the paper stated that “although Malaysia would have Islam as the official religion of the enlarged federation, there would be no hindrance placed on the practice of other religions. Complete freedom of religion would be guaranteed in the Federal Constitution”.

“This repugnant and oppressive decision of the court confirms the fears of our forefathers and gives justification to the voice of the 60% who were against joining the formation of Malaysia in 1963.”

Baru, who is also the assemblyman for the rural seat of Ba Kelalan, said the people of Sarawak are getting very close to, if they have not yet reached, “the sour end of the sugarcane” – a reference to the scepticism and doubts voiced by one of Malaysia's founding fathers, Tun Jugah Barieng, on the sincerity of Sarawak's long-term position in Malaysia.

“Today, not only it is the end of the sugarcane, it also leaves a bitter taste in our mouths,” added Baru.

Lawyer Karpal Singh said the constitutional guarantee did not limit East Malaysians to practising their religions in their own territories.

"As such, Christians from Sabah and Sarawak must be allowed to use the word in other parts of Malaysia or this will violate the agreement," he told The Malaysian Insider.

He said it was unfortunate that the agreement and its impact on Christians were not highlighted in the Court of Appeal. – October 28, 2013.

Follow @YahooMalaysia on LINE for daily news updates.

Comments on Yahoo pages are subject to our link to Comments Guidelines. You are responsible for any content that you post. Yahoo is not responsible or liable in any way for comments posted by its users. Yahoo does not in any way endorse or support comments made by its users.

  • In funeral procession, thousands chant ‘Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh’ (VIDEO) The Malay Mail Online
    In funeral procession, thousands chant ‘Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh! Karpal Singh’ (VIDEO)

    GEORGE TOWN, April 20 — The streets of Penang’s historical city centre roared with the voices of thousands calling out the name of their state’s beloved son — Karpal Singh.  Elbows jostled with... …

  • Raja Bomoh spouting mumbo-jumbo again The Malaysian Insider
    Raja Bomoh spouting mumbo-jumbo again

    Bomoh (shaman) Ibrahim Mat Zin (pic, third left) is in the headlines for the wrong reasons again, this time for conducting a cleansing ritual along KM306.1 of the North-South Expressway. The area has been in the spotlight since last Thursday after Bukit Gelugor MP Karpal Singh died when his Toyota Alphard was involved in a collision with a... …

  • Remains of Karpal’s aide to be flown back to India The Malaysian Insider
    Remains of Karpal’s aide to be flown back to India

    The remains of Karpal Singh’s personal aide Michael Cornelius, who died in Thursday's accident along with the Bukit Gelugor MP, will be flown back to India today, according to media reports. Prayers would be held for Michael, 39, at the Ipoh Hospital mortuary before his remains are transferred to the Kuala Lumpur International Airport, The... …